Home
 > 
Policies
 > 
Information for Authors

Transformative Publication

Last updated: 2022-04-30

A transformative journal is a type of journal that is in the process of transitioning from a subscription-based model to an open access publishing model. These journals are often affiliated with established subscription-based journals, and the goal of the transition is to increase the accessibility of research while also maintaining the high standards of peer review and editorial oversight that are associated with traditional subscription-based journals.

In order to be recognized as a transformative journal, a journal must meet certain criteria established by the Transformative Journal Framework of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). These criteria include:

  • Demonstrating a clear commitment to transitioning to a fully open access model over a set period of time.
  • Providing transparent information about the costs associated with publishing, including any fees that may be charged to authors.
  • Ensuring that the quality and standards of peer review and editorial oversight are maintained during the transition process.
  • Providing clear information about the licensing terms under which content is published.

Transformative Publication

Transformative publication in journals refers to the process by which traditional subscription-based journals transition to an open access publishing model. This transition involves changes to the journal's business model, editorial practices, and licensing agreements to make research articles freely available to readers without the need for a subscription or payment.

In the context of transformative publication, journals may take one of two approaches:

  • Hybrid Journals: Some subscription-based journals have adopted a hybrid approach to open access publishing. This involves charging authors a fee to make their articles open access, while still providing access to subscribers who pay for the journal's content. This approach allows journals to maintain their existing subscription model while offering authors the option to make their research more widely available.
  • Transformative Journals: Other journals have committed to a full transition to open access publishing. These journals are referred to as transformative journals and are recognized by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) as journals that are committed to making the transition to open access publishing while maintaining the high standards of peer review and editorial oversight associated with traditional subscription-based journals.

Benefits

What Authors Get?

Increased visibility and impact

By making research articles freely available to readers, transformative publication in journals can increase the visibility and impact of an author's research. This increased exposure can lead to more citations and greater recognition for the author's work.

Greater accessibility

Open access publishing makes research articles available to a wider audience, including researchers, students, and members of the public who may not have access to subscription-based journals. This can help to increase the accessibility of research and ensure that important findings are disseminated more widely.

Compliance with funding mandates

Many funding agencies require that research findings be made publicly available. By publishing in open access journals or choosing to make their articles open access in hybrid journals, authors can ensure compliance with these mandates.

Retention of copyright

In traditional subscription-based publishing models, authors often transfer their copyright to the publisher. In open access publishing models, authors typically retain their copyright and can retain control over how their work is used and disseminated.

Cost savings

In some cases, transformative publication in journals can be less expensive for authors than traditional subscription-based publishing models. This is because authors may be required to pay article processing charges in open access journals, but these fees may be lower than the cost of purchasing a subscription to the journal.

What Authors need to know?

Open access options

Transformative journals typically offer open access options for authors, either through a hybrid model or full open access publishing. Authors should consider their funding sources and the benefits of making their research available to a wider audience when deciding whether to choose an open access option.

Licensing Agreements

Authors should understand the licensing agreements associated with publishing in transformative journals. In some cases, authors may be required to sign over some or all of their copyright to the publisher. It is important to carefully review these agreements to ensure that authors retain the necessary rights to their work.

Peer review

Transformative publication in journals can increase the visibility and impact of an author's work by making it available to a wider audience. Authors should consider the potential benefits of open access publishing for their research and career development.

Visibility and Impact

Transformative publication in journals can increase the visibility and impact of an author's work by making it available to a wider audience. Authors should consider the potential benefits of open access publishing for their research and career development.

Funding mandates

Many funding agencies require that research findings be made publicly available. Authors should be aware of these mandates and should consider the open access options available to them when publishing in transformative journals.

Access to High-Quality Research

Subscription-based publishing ensures that readers have access to high-quality research articles that have undergone rigorous peer-review processes.

Timely Access

Readers can access new articles as soon as they are published, ensuring that they stay up-to-date with the latest research in their field.

Comprehensive Coverage

Subscription-based journals often cover a wide range of topics, providing readers with a comprehensive view of the latest research in their field.

High-Quality Graphics and Visuals

Subscription-based journals often include high-quality graphics, tables, and other visuals that help readers better understand the research being presented.

Quality Control

Subscription-based journals have a reputation for maintaining high-quality standards and ensuring that the research presented is reliable and accurate.

Access to Archives

Subscription-based journals often provide access to archives of past articles, allowing readers to access older research that may still be relevant to their work.

Strategies

  • Negotiating transformative agreements with publishers: Negotiating transformative agreements with publishers involves discussions and agreements between a journal and a publisher to transition from traditional subscription-based publishing to open access publishing. The goal of these agreements is to make scholarly research freely available to readers worldwide.Transformative agreements may take different forms, such as a hybrid model or a "read and publish" model. In a hybrid model, authors pay an article processing charge to make their work open access, while the rest of the content in the journal remains under a subscription-based model. In a "read and publish" model, institutions pay a fee to provide open access to all articles published in the journal.Negotiating these agreements can be complex and require careful consideration of financial and legal factors. However, transformative agreements offer a way for journals to promote open access publishing and comply with funding mandates, while also ensuring the sustainability of their operations.
  • Supporting open access publishing: Supporting open access publishing involves journals providing options for authors to publish their research in an open access format. Open access publishing allows readers to access research articles free of charge, without the need for a subscription or payment.Journals may offer full open access publishing options for authors, which involves charging an article processing charge (APC) to cover the costs of peer review and publishing. This fee is typically paid by the author or their funding institution, and allows the article to be freely accessible to all readers.Some journals may also offer discounts or waivers for authors who are unable to pay the full APC, in order to ensure that the cost of publishing does not become a barrier to open access. Additionally, some funding agencies may provide funding to cover the cost of open access publishing.By supporting open access publishing, journals can increase the visibility and impact of the research published in their journal, while also promoting transparency and accessibility in scholarly research. Open access publishing can also help authors comply with funding mandates and reach a wider audience, leading to greater citation rates and impact for their research.
  • Promoting open science practices: Promoting open science practices involves encouraging researchers to make their research process and data as transparent and accessible as possible. This can involve a range of practices, such as making research data available for reuse, sharing research protocols and methodologies, and pre-registering study designs.Journals can play an important role in promoting open science practices by requiring authors to adhere to certain standards for data sharing, reporting of results, and transparency. Journals may also provide guidelines and resources to help authors implement open science practices in their research.Promoting open science practices can lead to a number of benefits for the scientific community, including greater transparency and accountability in research, increased reproducibility of research results, and improved opportunities for collaboration and data reuse. By promoting open science practices, journals can help to advance the quality and impact of research, and promote a more inclusive and collaborative research culture.
  • Ensuring quality and impact: Ensuring quality and impact in scholarly publishing involves implementing rigorous peer review processes and providing high-quality editorial services to authors.Journals can ensure quality by using a double-blind peer review process, where both the author and the reviewer remain anonymous to each other. This helps to ensure that the review is based solely on the quality of the research, and not influenced by factors such as the author's reputation or the reviewer's personal biases.Additionally, journals can ensure impact by providing guidance to authors on how to write clear and engaging articles, and by promoting their articles through various channels, such as social media and academic networks. Journals may also track the citations of their articles and provide metrics to authors, to help them understand the impact of their research.To ensure quality and impact, journals may also have rigorous editorial policies in place, such as requiring authors to adhere to ethical standards for research and publication, and ensuring that articles are well-written, well-organized, and scientifically sound.By ensuring quality and impact in scholarly publishing, journals can help to advance the field of research and provide valuable contributions to the scientific community.

Further Correspondence

STM understands that getting a manuscript published is a big step for you and here we ensure that you do not face any difficulty in the process, for your ease we’re always here to help you all the time.

You can write to us at:[email protected] or can submit your query on the  Query Portal.

Query Portal